Key takeaways
- The organisation that filed the marker can remove it if it upholds your complaint, Cifas says.
- Cifas reviews whether the member followed the right procedures. It cannot recommend financial awards.
- The Financial Ombudsman Service looks at the financial business, not at Cifas. If it finds you lost money because of the marker, it can tell the business to put things right, and it may also order compensation for distress or inconvenience.
- The ICO looks at data protection failings. It does not award compensation and does not investigate fraud.
- The Ombudsman has a firm time limit: 6 months from the date on the final response. The ICO suggests 3 months, and Cifas states none.
This page compares the routes side by side. For a full walk-through of each step, see how to get a CIFAS marker removed. For the Ombudsman stage in detail, see complaining to the Financial Ombudsman about a fraud marker.
Who can you complain to about a CIFAS marker?
A CIFAS marker is registered by a Cifas member, such as a bank. Two of the four parts of Cifas’s filing standard are that the member has “reasonable grounds to believe” fraud or financial crime was committed or attempted, and that the evidence is “clear, relevant and rigorous”.
There are four bodies you can complain to, each with a different job:
- The filing member made the decision and can reverse it.
- Cifas runs the database and offers a review of the member’s handling.
- The Financial Ombudsman Service settles complaints about financial businesses, including whether one passed information to a fraud prevention agency unfairly.
- The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) deals with complaints that an organisation has not followed data protection law with your personal information.
Bank vs Cifas vs Ombudsman vs ICO: the routes compared
| Filing bank or member | Cifas | Financial Ombudsman Service | ICO | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it looks at | Your complaint about its decision to file the marker | Whether the member followed the right procedures | Whether the database information is accurate, whether the firm made a mistake or acted unfairly, and whether the filing test was met | Whether an organisation followed data protection law with your personal information |
| What it can do | Remove your details from the Cifas system if it upholds your complaint | Carry out an independent review with the member, and offer advice and guidance | If you lost money because of the marker, tell the business to put things right. It may also order compensation for distress or inconvenience | Tell the organisation to do more work or explain its position, which could mean correcting inaccuracies |
| What it can’t do | — | Recommend financial awards | Look at complaints against Cifas or other fraud prevention agencies | Award compensation, investigate fraud, or make an organisation apologise |
| Before you start | Nothing. This is the first step | A final response from the member | A complaint to the business, and either its final response or no final response within the time limit | A complaint to the organisation, which the ICO’s form asks you to attach |
| Time limit to complain | Usually 6 years from the problem or, if later, 3 years from when you knew or should have known you had cause to complain | None stated on Cifas’s complaint page | 6 months from the date on the final response, with limited exceptions | The ICO suggests 3 months from the organisation’s response. It still considers later complaints, but a delay may affect what it can do |
| Cost | No fee is stated in the sources we checked | Cifas says it will never charge for a DSAR or a complaint | Free. You don’t need to pay anyone to represent you | No fee is mentioned on the ICO’s complaint page |
| Published timescale | Up to 8 weeks for most complaints. 15 business days (35 in exceptional circumstances) for payment services and e-money complaints | Aims to resolve investigations within one month, though some take longer | Service-wide targets: 50% of cases resolved within 3 months and 80% within 6 months of acceptance | More detailed complaints currently reach a case officer around 10 months after submission |
| What to send | What you are complaining about and why the marker should be removed, with supporting documents and correspondence | Your full name and date of birth, the final response, and other supporting correspondence | The complaint form. The Ombudsman asks for more information later and also gathers evidence from the business | The organisation’s contact details, a summary and timeline, your complaint to it, and any subject access request you made |
Where the table comes from. Filing member: Cifas’s complaint page, the Ombudsman’s time limits and how to complain pages, and the FCA’s DISP 1.6 rules. Cifas: its complaint and DSAR pages. Ombudsman: its fraud markers, time limits, how to complain and service standards pages, and DISP 2.8. ICO: its data protection complaints page. All are listed under Sources below.
The Ombudsman’s timescales are service-wide targets across every type of case, not a figure for fraud marker complaints. The ICO’s figure is the wait before a case officer is assigned, not the time to a decision.
How do the routes fit together?
Complaining to the member that filed the marker comes first. After that, Cifas’s review, the Ombudsman and the ICO are separate routes. Neither the Ombudsman nor the ICO says you need Cifas’s review first. Cifas says its review can only start once you hold the member’s final response. If Cifas then finds the filing was correct and you still want to dispute it, it says the next step is the regulator or complaints scheme for that industry, which Cifas says is usually the Financial Ombudsman Service, though it depends on the industry.
The Ombudsman and the ICO answer different questions. The Ombudsman decides whether a financial business treated you fairly, using evidence from you, the business and any relevant third parties. The ICO considers whether data protection law was followed and can give its view. Both look at accuracy: the Ombudsman checks whether the information on the database is accurate, and the ICO may get an organisation to correct inaccuracies. The Ombudsman may tell a business to pay compensation. The ICO says it does not award compensation, and that only a court or tribunal can.
Published Ombudsman decisions show what an upheld complaint can look like. In decision DRN-6215869, the ombudsman partly upheld a complaint, finding that a building society had acted too hastily in filing the marker. It directed the society to remove the marker and pay £500 compensation, which covered the distress caused by both the marker and the closure of the account. That decision turned on its own facts and does not predict the outcome of any other complaint.
Challenging a CIFAS marker, step by step
This is the order Cifas describes, with the other routes after it.
- Finding out what is recorded. A data subject access request to Cifas is free, and Cifas must respond within one calendar month of receiving a complete form and supporting documents. See how to check if you have a CIFAS marker.
- A complaint to the member that filed it. Cifas asks you to explain what you are disputing and why, with supporting documents and correspondence. It says most disputes are resolved at this stage.
- A final response. If you are not satisfied with the member’s response, Cifas says you can ask it for a final response, which can be a letter or an email. The Ombudsman’s six-month limit runs from the date on it.
- The next routes. Cifas’s review, the Financial Ombudsman Service and the ICO are compared in the table above, and each has its own time limit. The full removal guide covers each in more depth.
Cifas says it will never charge you for a subject access request or a complaint, and it warns against paying third parties who promise a guaranteed removal. See what CIFAS marker removal costs.
Getting advice
These routes are described here so you can see how they differ. Which one suits your case depends on its facts. If you want help deciding, or you are close to a time limit, you can find a solicitor in our directory. We are independent and not affiliated with any firm listed.